Menu

Discussion Forum

New Discussion
Filtra

Discussion Closed This discussion was created more than 6 months ago and has been closed. To start a new discussion with a link back to this one, click here.

Issue with fillet

Posted 13 feb 2024, 07:49 GMT-5 11 Replies

Raffaella Acquaviva
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Hello guys. I am Electronics Engineering student in Politecnico di Milano and I am using Comsol for my thesis project. I have an issue with the fillet, in particular I'm able to built it in the geometry butn when I form the union, it becomes a straight line. I cannot increase the radius of the fillet as the structure is in the order of few um. Is it possible to change the grid of the points used by Comsol to build the union? Does anyone have the same issue? Thank you so much, Raffaella

11 Replies Last Post 15 feb 2024, 08:33 GMT-5
Acculution ApS Certified Consultant
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 13 feb 2024, 08:41 GMT-5

Have you tried a different tolerance?

-------------------
René Christensen, PhD
Acculution ApS
www.acculution.com
info@acculution.com
Have you tried a different tolerance?
Edgar J. Kaiser Certified Consultant
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 13 feb 2024, 08:41 GMT-5

Raffaella,

I am not sure if this is the issue, but you could try to change the geometry units to µm instead of m.

Cheers Edgar

-------------------
Edgar J. Kaiser
emPhys Physical Technology
www.emphys.com
Raffaella, I am not sure if this is the issue, but you could try to change the geometry units to µm instead of m. Cheers Edgar
Raffaella Acquaviva
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 13 feb 2024, 10:57 GMT-5

Have you tried a different tolerance? Hello René, yes I tried to change the absolute tolerance from nm to fm but nothing changes.

Thanks Raffaella

>Have you tried a different tolerance? Hello René, yes I tried to change the absolute tolerance from nm to fm but nothing changes. Thanks Raffaella
Raffaella Acquaviva
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 13 feb 2024, 11:02 GMT-5

Raffaella,

I am not sure if this is the issue, but you could try to change the geometry units to µm instead of m.

Cheers Edgar

Hello Edgar, I tried to change it too, but nothing works. It seems a sort of resolution problem depending on the dimension of the element that Comsol accepts as the lowest possible. In fact, if I modify the radius putting it equal to 300 nm, I see a sort of fillet (see my attatched screenshots).

Thanks, Raffaella

>Raffaella, > >I am not sure if this is the issue, but you could try to change the geometry units to µm instead of m. > >Cheers >Edgar Hello Edgar, I tried to change it too, but nothing works. It seems a sort of resolution problem depending on the dimension of the element that Comsol accepts as the lowest possible. In fact, if I modify the radius putting it equal to 300 nm, I see a sort of fillet (see my attatched screenshots). Thanks, Raffaella
Edgar J. Kaiser Certified Consultant
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 13 feb 2024, 11:06 GMT-5

I suggest you upload the model, so we can play with it.

-------------------
Edgar J. Kaiser
emPhys Physical Technology
www.emphys.com
I suggest you upload the model, so we can play with it.
Magnus Ringh COMSOL Employee

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 14 feb 2024, 07:10 GMT-5

Hi Raffaella,

This is a visualization artifact. Go to the Mesh settings and set a small Maximum element size on the fillet edge. Then you will get a mesh that shows the true fillet arc.

Best regards,

Magnus

Hi Raffaella, This is a visualization artifact. Go to the Mesh settings and set a small Maximum element size on the fillet edge. Then you will get a mesh that shows the true fillet arc. Best regards, Magnus
Raffaella Acquaviva
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 15 feb 2024, 05:08 GMT-5

I suggest you upload the model, so we can play with it.

Hello Edgar, here uploaded my projest with the fillet built. When you form the union, you can see that the fillet change structure. Thanks a lot for your haelp. Raffaella

>I suggest you upload the model, so we can play with it. Hello Edgar, here uploaded my projest with the fillet built. When you form the union, you can see that the fillet change structure. Thanks a lot for your haelp. Raffaella
Raffaella Acquaviva
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 15 feb 2024, 05:09 GMT-5

Hi Raffaella,

This is a visualization artifact. Go to the Mesh settings and set a small Maximum element size on the fillet edge. Then you will get a mesh that shows the true fillet arc.

Best regards,

Magnus

Hello Magnus, thanks for the suggestion. I put as max element size 1e-9 m and min size of 0.5e-9 m. But the problem occurs before defing the mesh, when we form the union of the geometry. Kind regards, Raffaella

>Hi Raffaella, > >This is a visualization artifact. Go to the Mesh settings and set a small Maximum element size on the fillet edge. Then you will get a mesh that shows the true fillet arc. > >Best regards, > >Magnus Hello Magnus, thanks for the suggestion. I put as max element size 1e-9 m and min size of 0.5e-9 m. But the problem occurs before defing the mesh, when we form the union of the geometry. Kind regards, Raffaella
Edgar J. Kaiser Certified Consultant
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 15 feb 2024, 06:54 GMT-5

Raffaella,

as Magnus pointed out it is a visualization effect in the geometry, probably because you have very large ratio in the dimensions of the thing.

Use an edge mesh for the fillet at the top of the meshing sequence, that properly resolves the curvature.

This way the curvature will be accounted for in the calculation and it will be shown in the result plots. The artifact will remain in the geometry visualization, but you can ignore it. Of course it would be nice if the geometry visualization avoided such artifacts that can create confusion (pinging COMSOL).

Cheers, Edgar

-------------------
Edgar J. Kaiser
emPhys Physical Technology
www.emphys.com
Raffaella, as Magnus pointed out it is a visualization effect in the geometry, probably because you have very large ratio in the dimensions of the thing. Use an edge mesh for the fillet at the top of the meshing sequence, that properly resolves the curvature. This way the curvature will be accounted for in the calculation and it will be shown in the result plots. The artifact will remain in the geometry visualization, but you can ignore it. Of course it would be nice if the geometry visualization avoided such artifacts that can create confusion (pinging COMSOL). Cheers, Edgar
Raffaella Acquaviva
Send Private Message Flag post as spam

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 15 feb 2024, 07:42 GMT-5

Raffaella,

as Magnus pointed out it is a visualization effect in the geometry, probably because you have very large ratio in the dimensions of the thing.

Use an edge mesh for the fillet at the top of the meshing sequence, that properly resolves the curvature.

This way the curvature will be accounted for in the calculation and it will be shown in the result plots. The artifact will remain in the geometry visualization, but you can ignore it. Of course it would be nice if the geometry visualization avoided such artifacts that can create confusion (pinging COMSOL).

Cheers, Edgar

Hello Edgar, thanks for your advise. Now I'm able to see the mesh on the fillet too. Thank you so much and have a nice day! Raffaella

>Raffaella, > >as Magnus pointed out it is a visualization effect in the geometry, probably because you have very large ratio in the dimensions of the thing. > >Use an edge mesh for the fillet at the top of the meshing sequence, that properly resolves the curvature. > >This way the curvature will be accounted for in the calculation and it will be shown in the result plots. The artifact will remain in the geometry visualization, but you can ignore it. Of course it would be nice if the geometry visualization avoided such artifacts that can create confusion (pinging COMSOL). > >Cheers, >Edgar Hello Edgar, thanks for your advise. Now I'm able to see the mesh on the fillet too. Thank you so much and have a nice day! Raffaella

Attachments:

Magnus Ringh COMSOL Employee

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 9 months ago 15 feb 2024, 08:33 GMT-5

Raffaella,

as Magnus pointed out it is a visualization effect in the geometry, probably because you have very large ratio in the dimensions of the thing.

Use an edge mesh for the fillet at the top of the meshing sequence, that properly resolves the curvature.

This way the curvature will be accounted for in the calculation and it will be shown in the result plots. The artifact will remain in the geometry visualization, but you can ignore it. Of course it would be nice if the geometry visualization avoided such artifacts that can create confusion (pinging COMSOL).

Cheers, Edgar

Hi Edgar,

Such an improvement is on our radar.

Best regards, Magnus

>Raffaella, > >as Magnus pointed out it is a visualization effect in the geometry, probably because you have very large ratio in the dimensions of the thing. > >Use an edge mesh for the fillet at the top of the meshing sequence, that properly resolves the curvature. > >This way the curvature will be accounted for in the calculation and it will be shown in the result plots. The artifact will remain in the geometry visualization, but you can ignore it. Of course it would be nice if the geometry visualization avoided such artifacts that can create confusion (pinging COMSOL). > >Cheers, >Edgar Hi Edgar, Such an improvement is on our radar. Best regards, Magnus

Note that while COMSOL employees may participate in the discussion forum, COMSOL® software users who are on-subscription should submit their questions via the Support Center for a more comprehensive response from the Technical Support team.

Suggested Content